
I'm very much a golden person.
What follows are some generalizations based upon my experiences. Because you have different experiences than I do, you may have different opinions. I respect them. Please respect mine.
1. Labs do have a lot of energy. The American trial Labrador is usually a very hot-blooded animal with lots of spirit and more than a little stubbornness. Some can be scatty, and others are furry lunkers that can’t be controlled without judicious application of the e-collar. A lot of these Labs also lack retrieving instinct and must be force-fetched. (The average working gundog should never need to go through it. It should be a natural retriever.) It’s still possible to find good lines of working Labrador that aren’t too extreme in this regard. However, the chances of getting one of these wild ones is too high these days. With goldens, high energy is something to still be breeding for. In fact, pet goldens are being bred that lack drive and instinct. If you get a golden, chances are it won’t be one of these wild dogs. (I really don’t like a very calm golden retriever, but I think if you had one that was as up as some of these Labs are, you would have problems very quickly).
2. Labs are not as easy to train for normal purposes as a golden. Now, for waterfowl and retriever trials, they are far better. But goldens are far easier to precision train for dog sports. As house dogs, I find them easier to housebreak and easier to teach simple obedience commands.
3. Labs are more neotenous than goldens are. This means that they don’t develop as many wolf-like behaviors as goldens develop.
4. Goldens have a better nose than Labradors. Goldens are also natural air scenters and quaterers, which is bad for a trial dog but very useful in a flushing retriever in heavy cover.
5. Goldens mature later than Labs. This is supposed to be a negative if you’re a trialer. I happen to like a dog that as a bit longer childhood, because then you have more time to put in foundations in your training and socialization.
6. My goldens have lived longer than the working Labs I’ve known. Now, this may no longer be the case, but when the Labs died at 10 or 11, my goldens still made it 13 and 14.
7. If there is a border collie of the gun dogs, the golden is it. Before BC’s became AKC dogs, goldens simply took over the obedience trial. If you wanted to do competitive obedience, you got a golden to start out. Then you figured out to do it with something harder– like a basenji.
8. I prefer setter and spaniel behavior in a hunting dog but with much more control. The golden has a lot of setter and spaniel quartering behavior. They aren’t great at speed as flushing dogs, but because they are so easy to train, it is easier to teach them how to quarter closer. Labs don’t have the golden’s nose, and I find their quartering behavior to be very different. They are either methodical like black Clumbers or they run around like black springers.
9. I have had three super smart golden retrievers, which have all been very easy to train. They also have been superb at problem solving. All three have figured out how to open doors on their own. One taught the other how to open the door. The current dog figured it out when she was about 5 months old.
10. “If everyone jumped off a bridge, would you do it?”
Labs are popular, and many are good working gundogs. If you want a trial dog, there are many more lines of working Lab than golden. If you want a dog that works in the old-fashioned way, that is very easy to train as a pet but takes longer to train as a retriever, I’d say go for a golden.
I’m biased toward goldens. I don’t deny this.
There are good Labs are there. There are many of them.
You do have to hunt to find a good golden. Good Labs are far more common.
It’s just the Labrador isn’t for me.
I’ve never actually written why I prefer goldens to Labs before. It may be that I just met the right goldens early on, and first impressions have a very strong impact upon perception.
I respect Labrador people for making their decisions. I’m sure their dogs are good.
It’s just that I like the old-fashioned retrievers. I like dogs that look like they belong in Edwardian shoots in the last halcyon days of the Empire. Call me romantic or a touch nostalgic, but the golden is the only common retriever that still has that mystique.








