• Home
  • About
  • Become my Patreon
  • Contact
  • Facebook

Canis lupus hominis

The Retriever, Dog, & Wildlife Blog

Feeds:
« More on African bullfrogs
Now here’s another one of those German HPR’s »

Are Drahthaars German wire-haired pointers?

February 24, 2010 by retrieverman

Source.

As I have written before, the HPR breeds from the continent have not split into show and working form in the same way that the specialized gun dogs from Britain and Ireland have.

However, there have been some splits. It is kind of inevitable. Dog shows are very expensive endeavors in terms of money and time. It is even more expensive to get a dog with both working titles and a show championship.

But in the HPR’s, the splits have been less dramatic– with one notable exception.

I hope that I can be forgiven for generally refusing to call German HPR’s pointers. Yes, they point, but they do many other things. They are not like the pointers you find on Southern plantations and quail preserves. They do point, but no pointer is expected to retrieve. And no pointer is supposed to be a good blood trail dog.  And no pointer is encouraged to hunt furred animals, like coyotes and foxes.

Calling the German HPR’s pointers limits their talent base in our minds. Too many people think they are just an index dog.

To remedy this problem that the English name for these dogs has given us, I have decided to go by their German names. The short-hair is the Kurzhaar.  The long-hair is the Langhaar. I still call the pudelpointer by its name, simply because that’s what its name is in German.

Then I called the wire-haired German HPR a “Drahthaar.” Well, that name has a problem. The dogs that are registered as Deustch Drahthaar are not exactly the same as the “German wire-haired pointer” that is registered with the AKC.

Superficially, the dogs look similar, but they are being bred to very different standards.

The dogs registered as Deustch Drahthaar have a registry and club called Verein Deutsch Drahthaar–Group North America. (Verein, BTW, means union.) Their club has a physical conformation standard, but it also has very strict behavioral conformation standards. The dogs have to go through what is called “performance testing” to evaluate their working abilities:

To insure the continued quest for improvement of performance, regulations were established which require that all VDD Drahthaar used for breeding must first meet certain field performance standards. This evaluation of performance is conducted at special field trails designed to demonstrate inherited qualities.

Now, I wish we actually had something like this for retrievers. There is a physical conformation standard, but the dogs must behave and perform like retrievers in order to be considered for breeding.

Wow. What a novel concept.

I’ve seen many German breed clubs that are like this one. Those Germans were onto something. The club for retrievers in Germany operates like this, but it is using the FCI standard for British retrievers, which means they may not be breeding for the most functional conformation.

This performance registry for Drahthaars is using a very different conformation standard. For example, the AKC standard doesn’t allow any black on the German wire-haired pointer’s coat, but the Drahthaars can come in black roan. (Kurzhaar from Germany can come in solid black).

But what I found interesting about the North American Deustch Drahthaar registry is that it says something like this on virtually every page:

Many breeders of the German Wirehaired Pointer (GWP) errantly refer to their breed as Drahthaar. In addition to significant differences in breed standard, the Wirehair has been bred without regulation or restriction since the late 1950’s, but especially without the performance testing that proves the ability of the Drahthaar. After years of unrestricted breeding and no versatile performance standards the German Wirehaired Pointer has evolved into a distinctly separate breed.

So I can’t call the wire-haired HPR registered with the AKC a Drahthaar.

But calling it a German wire-haired HPR requires too many syllables. It’s just like the Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever. Every time I say that breed’s name to an uninitiated person, that person thinks I just made it up. Fewer words and syllables are useful when naming a dog breed, even if the English language has some deficiencies.

The strictness of the Deutsch Drahthaar community means that they can consistently produce good quality dogs. And that policy has worked in Germany and Austria, where the Drahthaar is the most common working gun dog.

And because this breed is very different from the German wire-hair, I think I need to make a correction to something that was said at Westminster this year. The announcer said that the German wire-hair was the most common gun dog in Germany. This is not the case.

It is the Deutsch Drahthaar.

Even saying the name gets my Teutonic blood flowing.

***

Now, this linguistic problem doesn’t exist with Large and Small Münsterländers, Pudelpointers, Stichelhaars (which are not Drahthaars!), or Langhaars. Only the Weimaraner and the German short-haired and wire-haired HPR’s have been recognized by the AKC. (And the Weimaraner is actually a big game hound that later was developed into an HPR.)

They have yet to start splitting up.

***

I’ve read in several places that the German HPR’s can’t be trusted with children.

I think this video dispels that myth fairly well:

Source.

***

I remember writing a short story about a Drahthaar when I was in the ninth grade.

However, I can’t remember the details of it.

All I remember is the title of the story was “Drahthaar,” and I made it take place in Moravia or Bohemia.

Posted in dog breeding, dog breeds | Tagged Deustch Drahthaar, Drahthaar, German wire-haired pointer | 5 Comments

5 Responses

  1. on February 24, 2010 at 8:10 pm Bill

    I would really love to hear from a GWP fancier about what they are doing that is better for the dogs than the DD folks.

    I mean the DD standard even has a conformation component! So its not like these are working dogs that vary greatly like BCs and JRTs.

    The DD requirements may have over-shot the mark a little, as the testing requires hundreds of hours for even the most talented dogs, but i back the concept whole-heartedly.

    It should be OK for those who breed for ability to speak up and say that their pursuit is more noble than those who breed for beauty alongside bulldogs who cant breathe and beagles wearing eyeliner!


  2. on February 25, 2010 at 12:18 am Peggy Richter

    There are a few performance-based registries in the US for various breeds. The problem most of them have is that they are tiny in comparison to AKC and the same breed name is used for the different dogs. Most people associate a Golden Retriever with the AKC type rather than the field type. The first is the one that’s in the “dog books” you get at the library. It’s in the web sites for the vast majority of “how to find the perfect puppy”. At best, these guides give cursory refrence to the field type vice the bench type. And of course most of the money and prestige is to be found in the bench dogs. If you aren’t into outdoor sports, it’s certainly easier to breed a “show” GSD than it is to do so for either the protection sport GSD or even a herding GSD. In the show dog, you have to meet the genetic requirements for the physical “look” and then do some training / socialization, and spend some money on the shows and handler. For a field dog, you have to have the genetics for the physical requiremetns, the genetics for the working elements, PLUS a fairly intensive period of training and THEN also spend the money on trials.
    AKC and the KC opted not to go with a working requirement for their champions, or any kind of health certificate. There’s been a few attempts to put that in, but so far, they’ve failed. The current pressure and increasing demands for some kind of quality may drive both into doing at least something of the sort — or it may open the door for a new registry that does this and allows some reasonable “appendix” breeding system to prevent closed breeding pools.
    VR, Peggy Richter


  3. on March 15, 2010 at 5:18 am German Drahthaar

    […] GermanDrahthaar.org German-Drahthaar.org Featured links Not available… Related blogs Are drahthaars german wire-haired pointers? « retrieverman's weblog Sh.ch./ir. sh.ch./ international sh.ch./us ch. timo ii v … Irish ch. kimmax krystal klear of […]


  4. on March 16, 2010 at 1:00 pm Drahthaar Dogs

    […] DrahthaarDogs.org Drahthaar-Dogs.org Featured links Not available… Related blogs Are drahthaars german wire-haired pointers? « retrieverman's weblog Timo at gwpca nationals 2009 in usa | kimmax german wirehaired … Now here's another one of […]


  5. on March 17, 2010 at 10:09 am Drahthaar Dog

    […] Drahthaar-Dog.net DrahthaarDog.org Drahthaar-Dog.org Web links Not available… Related weblogs Are drahthaars german wire-haired pointers? « retrieverman's weblog Drahthaar training – wasser (1) – wasserschußfest | kimmax german … How to pick out a dog […]



Comments are closed.

  • Nature Blog Network
  • Like on Facebook

    The Retriever, Dog, and Wildlife Blog

    Promote Your Page Too
  • Blog Stats

    • 5,547,933 hits
  • Retrieverman’s Twitter

    • @BradA1878 Elk and black bear are very good. Never tried pronghorn. 1 day ago
    • It's spring time in West Virginia wp.me/phvWb-7xy 2 days ago
    • The morel of the story... wp.me/phvWb-7xt 2 days ago
    • Feathering out wp.me/phvWb-7xq 2 days ago
    • Merritt Clifton: German Shepherd Apologist wp.me/phvWb-7x4 1 week ago
  • Community

  • Google rank

    Check Google Page Rank
  • Archives

    • April 2015
    • March 2015
    • February 2015
    • January 2015
    • December 2014
    • November 2014
    • October 2014
    • September 2014
    • August 2014
    • July 2014
    • June 2014
    • May 2014
    • April 2014
    • March 2014
    • February 2014
    • January 2014
    • December 2013
    • November 2013
    • October 2013
    • September 2013
    • August 2013
    • July 2013
    • June 2013
    • May 2013
    • April 2013
    • March 2013
    • February 2013
    • January 2013
    • December 2012
    • November 2012
    • October 2012
    • September 2012
    • August 2012
    • July 2012
    • June 2012
    • May 2012
    • April 2012
    • March 2012
    • February 2012
    • January 2012
    • December 2011
    • November 2011
    • October 2011
    • September 2011
    • August 2011
    • July 2011
    • June 2011
    • May 2011
    • April 2011
    • March 2011
    • February 2011
    • January 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • July 2008
  • Recent Comments

    The Bearden Pack on The morel of the story…
    M.R.S. on The morel of the story…
    Will and Eko on It’s spring time in West…
    Labrador Retriever I… on Merritt Clifton: German Shephe…
    Myra on Merritt Clifton: German Shephe…
  • Meta

    • WordPress.com
  • Pages

    • About
    • Become my Patreon
    • Contact
    • Facebook
  • e college finder

    Online Colleges
    Online Colleges
  • Email Me

    retrieverman1[at]yahoo.com
  • Art

    • Conservation Photojournalism
    • Demon Puppy
    • Historical Hound
    • LolaDot Photography
    • Lucinda Coldrey
  • Blogroll

    • 2dogcrazy
    • Academy for Dog Trainers (Jean Donaldson)
    • Action for Sighthound Adoption and Protection
    • Agile Gold
    • Allie Chronicles
    • Almost Heaven
    • Alpine Publications
    • American Barbet
    • Ann and I
    • Ask Dr. Yin
    • Azawakh Idi! Idi! Idi!
    • B-More Bulldogs
    • Birdchick
    • Blacksheep Cardigans
    • Border (Collie) Wars
    • Born-to-Track News & Views
    • Brad Anderson
    • Bronwen Dickey
    • Camera Trap Codger
    • Caninest
    • Cao Preto
    • Chathamhill Dogs
    • Code Name: Farm Collie
    • Cold Wet Nose
    • Confessions of a Canine Junkie
    • Conservation Photojournalism
    • Crappy Taxidermy
    • Demon Puppy
    • DesertWindhounds
    • Dinsdale Photoblog
    • Djinn34
    • Dobermann Daze
    • Dog Breeds of the World
    • Dog Bytes
    • Dog Politics (UK)
    • Dog Spelled Foward
    • Dogs and Wolves (Elaine Chaika)
    • Dogs Don't Look Both Ways
    • Dogs, dogs, and more dogs
    • Dogsnhorses
    • Dogstar Academy
    • DogTime Blogs
    • Durrell Wildlife Trust Blog
    • Ella Bay Forever
    • Fallowfen Gundog Blog
    • FirstDogCharlie
    • For the Pits
    • Frogdog Blog
    • FromZooMy
    • Full Cry
    • Gamebird Litter
    • Glencuan Pointers
    • Gold Dog History
    • Golden Obsessions
    • Golden Retriever Comunidad
    • Grey's Days
    • Guiding Golden
    • Gundogdoc’s Blog
    • Happy Doggie Blog
    • Hemmingford Dog Blog
    • Historical Hound
    • Hoof & Paw
    • HT Training
    • Ian Dunbar
    • James Marchington
    • Julie Zickefoose
    • K-9 Solutions Dog Training Blog
    • KC Dog Blog
    • Kennel Jacklaine's
    • Leah DVM
    • Lehrhund
    • Lumi and Laddie
    • Lurchers, Terriers, and Ferrets
    • Musings of a Biologist and Dog Lover
    • My three pups
    • Mystery of My Hairless Chihuahua
    • National Lacy Dog Association
    • No Kill blog
    • Novaforesta Barbets
    • Olduvai George
    • One Nation Under Dog
    • One Pibble's Wish
    • Online Dog Training
    • Out Walking the Dog
    • Pedigree Dogs Exposed Blog
    • Penin kulmilla
    • Pippa's Blog
    • Pitter Patter
    • Pointing Dog Blog
    • Prick Eared
    • Rainwolves Weblog
    • Raising Maple–A Murray River Curly Coated Retriever
    • Rat Hunters
    • Rat Hunters
    • Responsible Dog
    • Retriever History
    • Samuel's Blog
    • Save the Pit Bull, Save the World
    • Scott Shalaway
    • Sherlock and Noah
    • Sixteen Paws
    • Smart Dogs
    • Stephen Bodio’s Querencia
    • Steve Dale's Pet World
    • Sugar The Golden Retriever
    • Swamp Dogs
    • Tails of Gold
    • Tattoos and Terriers
    • Techichi.org
    • The Bark Blog
    • The Calmo Dog Blog
    • The Cooper Project
    • The Daily Coyote
    • The Life of Jalo
    • The Other End of the Leash
    • The Poodle (and Dog) Blog
    • The Public Domain Kennel Club
    • Totally Dogs
    • Turid Rugaas
    • Tyson the Pit Bull
    • Utah Neff
    • Welcome to Chelsea’s World
    • Working Cocker Spaniels
    • YesBiscuit!
  • Dog links

    • Apso Rescue- Colorado
    • Ariosa Spanish water dogs
    • Back to Basics to Improve the Breeding Selection Process by Robert Milner
    • Bi-Mar Pomeranians
    • Collie Family Tree
    • Dog +R/-P Resource Page
    • Dog Breeds of the World
    • Dog Phylogenetic Tree
    • Dog School Tv
    • Evolution of the German Shepherd in 30 Generations
    • Flat-coat Library
    • Golden Retriever Club of America's National Health Survey
    • Golden Retriever Rescue in Nebraska
    • Gundogz
    • Gyldenpels
    • HeatherWeb
    • Huggable Goldendoodles
    • Inbreeding as a way to select against genetic disorders?
    • Is the Closed Registry System Doomed?
    • Krassesrudel
    • Louter Creek Red Hunting Poodles
    • Mac Barwick's Bloodhound History
    • Martin's Goldens
    • Newfie World
    • Old Time Farm Shepherd
    • Robert Milner’s Retriever Training Site
    • Some Practical Solutions to Some Welfare Problems in Dog Breeding
    • Telescope: Farley Mowat–CBC Archives (Features St. John's water dogs)
    • The "Blue Collar" Retriever
    • The "Ideal" Golden Retriever: How Do You Find Such an Animal?
    • The Bark
    • The Chinese Crested Shrine
    • The Honey Wolf
    • The Truth about Fox Pens
    • Things to consider before getting a Field Trial Golden Retriever
    • Tuska Homma Catahoulas
    • UK Golden Retriever Health Survey
    • Using 'Dominance' To Explain Dog Behavior Is Old Hat
    • What's wrong with using 'dominance' to explain the behaviour of dogs?
    • Zomarick Golden retrievers
  • Must Reads

    • Border Wars Inbred Mistakes Posts
    • How to breed dogs with stronger immune systems?
    • MHC, DLA, WTF?
  • Other Links

    • The Heck Cattle of Devon
  • politics

    • Ed Schultz
    • Gerry Spence
    • Huffington Post
    • Kicking Ass
    • Of Principalities and Powers
    • Shannyn Moore
    • Thom Hartmann
    • West Virginia Blue
  • Poodle and Water Dog History

    • History of Newfoundland Dogs
    • History of the Buccleuch Labrador
    • Origin of the Cao de Castro Laboreiro
    • Poodle History-Ship's Dogs
  • Reminder for me

    • Reminder
  • Zoology

    • Centre for Fortean Zoology
    • Ella Bay Forever
    • NatureBreak.org
  • Subscribe to Retrieverman's Weblog by Email
  • Revolver map

    Map

  • Top Posts

    • The strangest shark story ever
  • Blog Catalog Member

    Cats, Dogs and Other Pet Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
  • SiteCounter


  • Donate to this blog

  • Top 50 Northwest Dog Blogs

    top 50 dog blogs
  • Top Dog

    Top Dog Blog
  • This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Blog at WordPress.com.

The MistyLook Theme.


Follow

Build a website with WordPress.com
%d bloggers like this: